Workability of concrete mix (concrete): what is it and why do builders need this characteristic

Concrete’s workability has a significant impact on its performance and quality. It describes the ease with which a concrete mix can be worked with, moved, and installed without sacrificing its intended qualities. A workable mix makes it possible for builders to create an even, smooth surface and guarantees that the concrete efficiently fills all of the voids in the formwork.

Workability is something that builders must consider in order to prevent problems during construction. Overly stiff concrete can be challenging to work with, which can result in issues like uneven surfaces or poor compaction. Conversely, an overly loose mixture may result in segregation, which weakens the final product’s strength and durability as the mix’s constituent parts separate.

Realizing and managing workability contributes to the construction of high-caliber concrete structures. It affects the concrete’s longevity and long-term performance in addition to its ease of placement. Builders can improve the longevity of their concrete structures and the efficiency of the construction process by striking the correct balance.

What is it

In practical terms, the ease and simplicity of installing concrete without delamination is referred to as its workability. However, the indicator, which also depends on the concrete’s compaction, is not exhausted by these categories. Therefore, workability—which is important for large concrete structures—is inappropriate for thin-walled and heavily reinforced elements.

You must take into account the concrete compaction process in order to comprehend workability. Compaction, which involves eliminating air from the mixture to reach maximum density in a specific configuration, can be accomplished by ramming and vibration methods.

1. Adhesion between individual components in the solution (internal seal).
2. Adhesion of concrete and reinforcement surface (surface).

A portion of the compaction force is applied to shake the formwork and vibrate the particles that have been seized. Energy in this context denotes both productive and ineffective labor. Overcoming internal/surface adhesion is a useful endeavor. Solutions are categorized into classes based on workability, or how well the mixture fits into the form and occupies it without leaving any gaps.

Although rigid mixtures are typically more durable, you can achieve maximum density with a well-placed solution. Workability and consistency are closely related concepts that govern the properties of the mixture, shape retention, and plastic deformation capacity of the material. However, if liquid concrete is to be described by its consistency, then both liquid and frozen concrete should be used (since this metric directly influences density).

Resilient mixtures are referred to as mobile, while inflexible mixtures are known as rigid. The relationship is as follows: the larger the particle size, the greater the resistance and the less mobile and workable the mixture. This is because the component particles’ adhesion to the formwork walls and to each other affects this parameter.

More water can be added to the solution to improve mobility, but doing so will degrade the monolith’s quality and make it more brittle and prone to deformation (water evaporates when cracks, chips, or delamination appear). Adding unique additives to the mixture—referred to as plasticizers—is a better approach.

It is crucial to maintain equilibrium even though the workability of the mixture is thought to be a key indicator that influences the comfort of labor and the density of the monolith, which determines its capacity to take on the desired shape. Although the overly liquid solution is poured quite well, it can still seep inside the concrete pillow and through the gaps in the formwork caused by the boards (seeping without creating the desired layer thickness from above).

It is important to keep in mind that the solution may become immobile when assigning a workability grade due to various factors.

Regulatory documents

Several GOSTs, including 7473–94, take into account the properties of the workability of concrete mix. lays out the general specifications for concrete solutions and describes how they are categorized; 10181.1-81 takes into account the procedures and equipment needed to test solutions for viability.

GOST 10181.1-81

This GOST takes into account the procedures used to evaluate the solution’s viability. You can identify the best indicators for use in a given area and gain a better understanding of the characteristics and qualities of mixtures by using the methods for classifying materials based on workability that have been described. Cone slump and special devices are the two main methods, depending on the rigidity and mobility values.

The most versatile technique for figuring out the characteristics of concrete—which can be applied to any kind of material—is cone slump. However, investigations utilizing specialized equipment are typically conducted for stiffer mixtures that cannot be categorized by cone slump.

Devices

A unique metal cone with handles and stops, that is truncated and has a funnel, is used to test cone slump. Two instruments are used to measure the degree of rigidity: a large metal disk with six holes that is lowered on a tripod and a cylinder with a tripod, both of which are used to create a vibrating table in the shape of a platform that vibrates at a speed of roughly 3000 vibrations per minute and an amplitude of about 0.5 millimeters.

Testing Methodology

Cone settlement testing is required for all mixtures, and it is governed by GOST.

• Installing a 30-centimeter-high cone on a flat steel sheet.
• Filling the mold with the mixture through a funnel, laying it in 3 layers of the same thickness with bayoneting each layer. Bayoneting one layer 25 times with a rod with rounded edges, 16 millimeters in cross-section and 600 millimeters in length.
• Removing the funnel, removing excess concrete with a trowel at the level of the upper cut of the cone.
• Removing the cone slowly and without shaking, for 3-7 seconds (according to GOST).
• Measuring with a ruler with divisions of a maximum of 0.5 centimeters of difference between the upper cut of the cone and the top of the settled concrete mortar. This difference determines the level of mobility.
• Repeat testing with a full repetition of all stages – for reliability, finding the arithmetic mean between 2 values.

• P1 – spread of 1-4 centimeters;
• P2 – 5-9 centimeters;
• P3 – 10-15 centimeters;
• P4 – a difference of 16-20 centimeters;
• P5 – more than 20 centimeters.

An enlarged cone is used for testing concrete with fillers larger than 40 millimeters, and the result is multiplied by a coefficient of 0.67. When O.K. = 0, a unique (second type) device is used for testing.

The device is fixed firmly to the vibration platform (it needs to have a flange), and a hollow cylinder is filled with a concrete cone. Next, the tripod is rotated to allow the disk to firmly position itself beneath the cone and be secured with a clamping screw. Next, the disk needs to be lowered onto the sample’s surface, and the stopwatch needs to be started at the same time as the vibration is turned on. When the solution is forced through any two of the disk’s six holes, counting stops. The outcome in seconds indicates the mixture’s degree of rigidity.

GOST 7473-94

There is a table in this document that breaks down concrete grades according to workability. In addition, the standard details the maximum percentage error in the component ratios (1% for binders and plasticizers, 2% for fillers), the composition of the solution, and the requirements for the water used for mixing.

The following metrics are used to determine workability: rigidity (vibration time in seconds) and mobility (cone settlement).

The ease with which a concrete mix can be combined, laid, and polished without sacrificing its quality is referred to as workability. For builders, this feature is essential as it impacts how easily the concrete can be handled and shaped to ensure that it fills all the spaces in the formwork and produces a smooth, long-lasting surface. A well-workable mix can increase the overall strength and finish of the concrete structure while also saving time and money on labor.

Application

The concrete’s workability and shape stability dictate the solution’s range of applications.

The formwork configuration, the pouring conditions and characteristics, the surrounding temperature, and other significant factors all play a significant role in the decision. Thus, choose the intended indicator for each unique situation. However, there are standard requirements for indicators when carrying out specific tasks.

• Industry, monolithic works and the creation of concrete products – P2-P3 (cone settlement in the region of 5-15 centimeters). Vibration is a must, and when laying on large areas, high labor costs are expected.
• Narrow formwork, densely reinforced structures, columns, and other hard-to-reach places – P4 (O.K. 16-20 centimeters). The mixture is plastic, fills the form well even without a vibrator.
• Laying with a concrete pump – it is also worth choosing P4.
• Concrete pump and dense reinforcement – P5 (O.K. 21-25 centimeters), which are prepared with superplasticizers and the introduction of special small fillers into the composition.

Comprehending the concrete’s workability is essential for construction projects to be successful. This characteristic has an impact on how simple it is to mix, move, and install concrete. When the concrete is sufficiently workable, all of the voids in the formwork are filled, creating a smooth, level surface and lowering the possibility of flaws.

In order to achieve the desired finish and structural integrity, builders must take workability into account. An excessively dry mixture could be difficult to work with and result in uneven surfaces, whereas an excessively wet mixture could make the finished product less strong. Achieving the ideal balance can be facilitated by modifying the water content and applying the proper admixtures.

All things considered, managing the workability of concrete properly contributes to the creation of strong, long-lasting structures. Builders can increase productivity and guarantee that their concrete will function well for the duration of its life by taking note of this feature.

Video on the topic

The influence of mineral additives on the properties of concrete mix and concrete

OOO RBU No. 2 Video concrete mobility

Concrete density and its types. How to increase concrete density.

Concrete mix selection chart and control batch | Concrete school

Incoming inspection of concrete mix according to GOST 10181 2000

Workability and slump of concrete mix cone – all about concrete plasticity | Concrete school

Abrams cone KA-1 for determining the mobility of concrete mix

How to check concrete for mobility? // Improvement.rf