Which floors are better – reinforced concrete or wooden?

It’s critical to comprehend the particular advantages and disadvantages of each option when deciding between reinforced concrete and wooden floors for your construction project. Because of their strength and longevity, reinforced concrete floors are a popular option for high-traffic and commercial areas. They offer a strong, resilient foundation that is able to support large loads and withstand deterioration.

Wooden floors, however, provide a distinct set of benefits. They make a place feel comfortable and welcoming by adding warmth and a natural aesthetic. Additionally, wood is typically easier to work with and offers greater flexibility for a wider range of designs and renovations.

We’ll go over the important things to think about in this post when choosing between these two flooring options. When building a new home, remodeling an old one, or working on a business project, knowing the benefits and drawbacks of hardwood floors versus reinforced concrete will enable you to make the decision that best meets your requirements.

Feature Reinforced Concrete Floors Wooden Floors
Durability High, long-lasting, resistant to wear and heavy loads Varies, generally less durable, can be damaged by moisture and pests
Maintenance Low, requires minimal upkeep Higher, needs regular treatment and checks for damage
Insulation Good, but may require additional insulation for temperature control Better natural insulation, warmer underfoot
Soundproofing Excellent at soundproofing due to mass Less effective, may need additional soundproofing measures
Cost Higher initial cost, but potentially lower long-term costs Lower initial cost, but may incur higher maintenance costs
Installation Time Longer, requires curing time and professional installation Quicker to install, can be a DIY project

Wooden floors

These kinds of floors have long been common in private construction. This is a lightweight, aesthetically pleasing, reasonably priced, and eco-friendly material. Beams made of wood or logs serve as the floor’s supporting structure. They need to have every requirement met, including deflection indicators—having a reserve is preferable.

Additionally, the type of finished floor determines its characteristics and dependability. They could have a composite cross-section, be constructed entirely of wood, or even be two-story buildings.

It is crucial to consider the cross-section of the beams because they support the majority of the weight. Based on the separations between the load-bearing walls, it is chosen. The framework may consist solely of beams or of logs that are later covered in boards. Such a structure will be less expensive if you choose to install only beams, but impact noise will not be blocked. In other words, it is easy to hear any movement of people on the floors. Soundproofing material is installed between the beams if the logs are first placed on them. Consequently, there won’t be any noise.

The so-called roll is what makes up the ceiling itself. The flooring is made of boards or planks of wood that are positioned in between the beams. Ceiling finishes come in a wide variety. Plastering is a common solution, but a more advanced approach would be to cover the surface with slabs of plasterboard.

Pros and cons of wooden floors

When discussing the benefits of this type of construction, it is important to note that they

  • Distinguished by the low cost of both the material itself and delivery and installation work.
  • Excellent for lightweight foundations.
  • Used in conditions of "difficult" soils.
  • Can be installed manually, without specialized equipment or builders.
  • Easy and quick to install.
  • Environmentally friendly. The wood does not contain any aggressive preparations, there is no reinforcement.

Practical! Every beam in the material you purchase needs to be thoroughly inspected. There shouldn’t be any fractures or indications of a parasite infestation.

However, there are a number of drawbacks to these kinds of structures as well. As an illustration,

  • Rodents or insects can gnaw through wood. It is susceptible to mold and mildew.
  • Requires treatment with special preservative compounds. Otherwise the wood will rot. Periodically it is necessary to impregnate the wood with antiseptics. However, even if you perform high-quality wood processing, you will not get 100% protection from rot. Also, to prevent the process of rotting, you will need to organize a high-quality ventilation system.
  • The beams will have to be sheathed on both sides, and the space between them must be filled with insulation and sound insulation.

  • Laying wooden elements requires a lot of effort and time.
  • The service life of such structures is significantly shorter than that of concrete. In addition, over time, the wood will begin to sag a little, and creaking may appear.
  • Wooden floors are not recommended for use in the construction of multi-storey buildings, as well as if the building is located in a seismically hazardous zone, where the indicators reach 7 points.
  • Since wood is highly flammable, you will also have to treat the beams with fire retardants. Or you can use special fire-retardant varnishes or paints.
  • If the span is quite large (more than 6 meters), then in this case the structure will require reinforcement, and therefore additional materials. You will need to buy beams with a larger cross-section. This means that the thickness of the entire floor will also be increased.
  • Such products cannot be used in damp rooms. This means that for showers, toilets, laundries and bathrooms you need to use reinforced concrete structures.
  • In those places where the floors adjoin the chimney, you will have to make thermal insulation seams.

Therefore, it makes sense to give the option with reinforced concrete structures some thought, especially if finances permit and we’re talking about a multi-story building.

It’s important to consider aspects like cost, upkeep, and durability when deciding between wooden floors and reinforced concrete. Because of their durability, strength, and low maintenance requirements, reinforced concrete floors are a great choice for high-traffic areas and buildings that need to maintain their structural integrity. Conversely, wooden floors are less durable than concrete and may require more frequent maintenance. However, they are aesthetically pleasing, cozy, and simple to install. Making an informed choice based on your unique requirements and preferences is made easier when you are aware of these distinctions.

Reinforced concrete floors

Items of this kind include:

  • Precast hollow-core reinforced concrete slabs. They are manufactured in factories, so there are standard models on sale with a width of 1.0, 1.2 and 1.5 meters. The thickness of the products is 220 mm. The length can be from 2.4 to 9.0 meters. Slabs of this type are distinguished by their large weight. One "square" of such a slab will weigh at least 300 kg. Therefore, it is necessary to understand that the supporting structures must withstand their weight. In addition, you will have to free up space near the house, since the products are delivered and then installed using a truck crane.
  • Monolithic reinforced concrete slabs. They can be flat or ribbed. For their installation, formwork is necessarily built and reinforcement is performed. The thickness of monolithic slabs is slightly less – 200 mm. They are also only suitable for spans less than 4.5 m. But despite the smaller thickness, one "square" of such a slab will weigh more – 480 kg. If you want to use lightweight structures, then you should choose ribbed slabs. But in this case, it will be necessary to make more complex formwork.
  • Combined floors, which are called precast-monolithic. The design of such products may differ. But most often, builders use the option when load-bearing monolithic beams made of rolled profiles are used.

Even though these are sturdy and dependable structures, you must weigh the benefits and drawbacks of each before making a decision.

Advantages of floors

It is important to first consider the benefits. There are plenty of them in reinforced concrete. As an illustration, consider these goods:

  • They are not susceptible to attacks by rodents and insects.
  • Suitable for brick, concrete houses, buildings made of gas blocks.
  • Have excellent mechanical strength. If before laying wooden beams it is necessary to clarify their bending strength, then in the case of reinforced concrete such a question does not arise at all.
  • Have a long service life. Such floors will not change their characteristics for more than 50 years.
  • Operation speed. Reinforced concrete floors can be laid in a few hours.
  • Fireproof. To do this, you don’t need to think about specialized impregnations or paintwork.
  • They have excellent sound and heat insulation parameters.
  • Can be installed regardless of seismic soil parameters.
  • Does not require expensive finishing.
  • Allows the construction of larger buildings.
  • Does not require additional insulation and ventilation.
  • Suitable for construction of premises with high humidity. Precast concrete products are used for saunas, baths, showers and other visits.
  • Allows you to lay tiles as a floor covering.
  • They do not “eat up” the ceiling height due to their thickness.

Of course, there are many benefits, but there are drawbacks as well.

Disadvantages of reinforced concrete floors

The cost of the problem is its primary drawback. In addition to the material itself, you will also need to pay for the use of heavy construction equipment. The cost of hiring the installation equipment and the laborers themselves must also be covered. Besides, the car with the slabs needs to get up to the house in some way. Should you lack a gate and there are numerous buildings in the vicinity, the driveway will be obstructed.

It’s also important to draw attention to drawbacks like these:

  • High weight of finished slabs. This means that the foundation of the house and the walls themselves must be very strong. Or you will have to strengthen the structure, and this is even more financial investment.
  • Possibility of installation error. There is a risk that a so-called cold bridge will appear.
  • To install a finished ceiling, you will have to rent or buy expensive drills and drilling machines.

Additionally, there’s a chance that the reinforcement—like a wi-fi router—located in the slabs will interfere with the signal. Some people think that metal has a bad impact on the individual.

Of course, there aren’t many options if you’re building a multi-story home. Installing reinforced concrete floors is a must. Just don’t save money and purchase handmade goods.

It’s important to take the particular requirements and project conditions into account when deciding between hardwood floors and reinforced concrete. Because of their strength and durability, reinforced concrete floors are perfect for heavy loads and high traffic areas. Their longevity and safety are increased by their resistance to fire and pests. In contrast to wooden floors, they can be more expensive and take longer to install.

Conversely, wooden floors give a room coziness and visual appeal. For certain applications, they can be more economical, and they are typically faster and simpler to install. In addition to offering superior sound absorption, wooden floors have a natural appearance that many find appealing. On the other hand, they might need more upkeep over time and lose their durability in situations with high moisture content or heavy loads.

The ideal option will ultimately rely on your preferences, your budget, and the way you want the space to be used. A well-informed decision can be made by weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each option in light of your unique needs. Whether you prefer the strength of reinforced concrete or the beauty of wood, each type of flooring has special benefits that are suitable for a variety of situations.

Video on the topic

MAIN OPTIONS FOR INTERFLOOR FLOORING IN A HOUSE. WHICH IS MORE EXPENSIVE MONOLITH OR VOYAGE SLABS

Interfloor slabs. Floor slabs vs. wooden floors

🔴 THE WHOLE TRUTH ABOUT COVERING FROM PLATES 🔴 The whole process of installing hollow-core floor slabs, all the disadvantages.

5 reasons why you should not make wooden floors in a house made of gas blocks or in a brick house

WOODEN, INTERFLOOR or ATTIC floor in a house made of aerated concrete. "Build and Live".

Which aspect of concrete application are you most interested in?
Share to friends
Dmitry Sokolov

Chief engineer in a large construction company. I have extensive experience in managing construction projects and implementing modern technologies.

Rate author
StroyComfort1.com
Add a comment